VOLUME 54 | NUMBER 1.2 | FEBRUARY 2019
"Are you accepting new patients?" A pilot field experiment on telephonebased gatekeeping and Black patients access to pediatric care
Study Objectives: To determine whether name and accent cues that the caller is Black shape physician offices’ responses to telephonebased requests for wellchild visits.
Method and Data: In this pilot study, we employed a quasiexperimental audit design and examined a stratified national sample of pediatric and family practice offices. Our final data include information from 205 audits (410 completed phone calls). Qualitative data were blindcoded into binary variables. Our casecontrol comparisons using McNemar's tests focused on acceptance of patients, withholding information, shaping conversations, and misattributions.
Findings: Compared to the control group, “Black” auditors were less likely to be told an office was accepting new patients and were more likely to experience both withholding behaviors and misattributions about public insurance. The strength of associations varied according to whether the cue was based on name or accent. Additionally, the likelihood and ways office personnel communicated that they were not accepting patients varied by region.
Conclusions: Linguistic profiling over the telephone is an aspect of structural racism that should be further studied and perhaps integrated into efforts to promote equitable access to care. Future research should look reactions to both name and accent, taking practice characteristics and regional differences into consideration.
Copyright© 2018, Health Research & Educational Trust. All rights reserved. Content Disclaimer
Health Research & Educational Trust, 155 North Wacker, 4th Floor Chicago, IL 60606 (312) 422.2600